Don’t get me wrong, i love the hp movies. But when i say i want a book to turn into a movie, i want a detailed description of what they do every day and not cut out important things. Like all the quidditch games, and Lilly and Snape’s story. It upsets me.

But I feel more like this is real canon, even if the books don’t state it. Harry is too forgiving, but I don’t know how anyone finds that much empathy for someone who had such a direct role in his parents’ deaths without having been in their shoes and partially to blame for causing the death of someone they’d have done anything to protect. Harry’s guilt over Sirius helped him relate to Snape.